| « Parent Wants Book Banned from School District | Worst Movie Adaptations » |
Ink Tue Aug 07 2007
Worst Movies
What was the worst movie adaptation of a book?
— Alice Maggio / Comments (7)
| « Parent Wants Book Banned from School District | Worst Movie Adaptations » |
What was the worst movie adaptation of a book?
— Alice Maggio / Comments (7)
I really enjoyed Ghostworld, and then I got almost angry at the adaptation after I read the comic. There were all sorts of things they left in the film that made no sense (like the blue jeans on the sidewalk) that kind of came together in the comic book.
I can't think of any really horrible ones at the moment, although I'm sure I've seen them, but I was quite upset with V for Vendetta and how they forced romance into the story. They also managed to make it all about 9/11 when the novel is not about that at all. It was really disappointing.
There are so many bad ones, but the worst one, in my opinion, may not have been made yet. I am utterly horrified at the casting and directorial choices for The Time Traveler's Wife, even though it's still in pre-production. I think they're going to fuck it up royally.
My vote is for Hannibal. Or possibly The Fountainhead.
The Fountainhead is an EXCELLENT choice - I had the misfortune to see it for the first time a few months ago - retch!
I would like to nominate The Color Purple and The Shipping News - neither of which are terrible movies. The Color Purple b/c I thought Shug & Celie's "sexual healing" was very relevant in the book whereas it just got chopped out of the movie altogether. I choose The Shipping News, b/c at no point in the movie did Kevin Spacey look like a sad-sack loser - he was at all times just an arm's length away from a movie star, which really bummed me out.
I'd say Less Than Zero, since the movie adaptation took on a wholly different meaning than the book and even the author refused to see it, hahaha.
In this debut novel, high school English teacher Peter Ferry witnesses a fatal car accident and becomes obsessed with learning about the life of the victim, Lisa Kim.
Join us at The Book Cellar at 4736-38 N. Lincoln Ave. (map) to discuss the book. We'll meet on Monday, November 9, at 7:30pm. New members are always welcome!

November 9
Travel Writing
by Peter Ferry

October 12
Lords of the Levee
by Herman Kogan and Lloyd Wendt
September 14
The Echo Maker
by Richard Powers
August 10
La Perdida
by Jessica Abel
July 13
Every Crooked Pot
by Renee Rosen
June 8
Cat's Cradle
by Kurt Vonnegut
May 11
Passing
by Nella Larsen
April 13
Then We Came to the End
by Joshua Ferris
March 16
The Book of Ralph
by John McNally
February 9
A River Runs Through It
by Norman Maclean
January 12
A Raisin in the Sun
by Lorraine Hansberry
~*~

Sat Nov 21 2009
Open Books Grand Opening
Sun Nov 22 2009
Open Books Grand Opening
Mon Nov 23 2009
Going Pro: How to Take Your Literary Venture to the Next Level
Mon Nov 23 2009
Eye of the Sandman Screening and Discussion @ Gene Siskel Film Center
Tue Nov 24 2009
Chicago Moth StorySLAM: BLUNDERS
Alice / August 7, 2007 9:54 AM
I was scarred for life after being forced to watch The Great Gatsby with Robert Redford and Mia Farrow in high school. Love the book. Hated the film.