Gapers Block has ceased publication.

Gapers Block published from April 22, 2003 to Jan. 1, 2016. The site will remain up in archive form. Please visit Third Coast Review, a new site by several GB alumni.
 Thank you for your readership and contributions. 


Monday, February 26

Gapers Block

Gapers Block on Facebook Gapers Block on Flickr Gapers Block on Twitter The Gapers Block Tumblr

« Video Premiere: Paper Thick Walls' "Orange Tree" Best Bets at the North Coast Music Festival »

Feature Thu Sep 01 2011

Janis Ian: I'll Come Up Singing For You, Even When I'm Down

Quick quiz: Which musician spoke of this auspicious start to her career in music? "A radio station in Atlanta dared to put [my song] in rotation, and someone burned the station down. Strangers walked up to me in restaurants and spit in my food... one [fan] letter would thank me for speaking out, the next would have razor blades taped to the envelope so I'd shred my fingers opening it... People threatened to burn down the venues I worked in, to run me over in the street, to shoot me while I was on stage."

Hint: she was only 15 at the time.

Janis Ian (Photo by Peter Cunningham)

Janis Ian's "Society's Child" brought heat from all directions. Stations bold enough to play it were rewarded with equal doses of accolade and venom from listeners. A sensitively wrought portrait of a doomed interracial relationship, "Society's Child" is compelling enough on its own merits, but in a culturally abraded year like 1965, it was spark applied to powder. Read that first paragraph again: Razorblades. Fire. Guns. This isn't cowardly internet dweebs railing against Rebecca Black's auto-tuning; "Society's Child" brought out primal conflicts in the hearts of people who felt that the civil rights struggles throughout the U.S. represented the end of civilization as we know it, and they pushed back with all the violence and bile they could muster.

To no avail. "Society's Child" was a bona-fide radio hit, gaining country-wide acceptance following a glowing review of her music on Leonard Bernstein's one-hour TV special Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution. The respected orchestral composer's stamp of approval made Ian's music safe for timid radio programmers - KRLA in Los Angeles even took out a full-page ad apologizing to Ian for previously blacklisting her music. Far from a time-capsule piece that requires historical context, "Society's Child" still retains its literary and emotional power to this day, and it made Janis Ian a star at 15.

Janis Ian on The Tonight Show, 1967. (Photo by Gilbert.)

Though she continued to release music of equal quality, by the time of her underrated fifth album, 1971's Present Company, Ian had been dropped from her record company due to lack of radio hits. 1974's Stars returned Ian to the radio waves with the beautiful title track, a sweet ode to the performing life written after hearing Don McLean's "Vincent" for the first time, but her next hit is the one you probably know the best. 1975's "At Seventeen" sent Ian rocketing back to the top of the charts for the first time in a decade. Her observations on loss, betrayal, loneliness, and eventual relief and redemption caught the public imagination, and the Between the Lines album sold over a million copies. (Bonus hip cred: "At Seventeen" was the first song performed on a struggling TV program no one remembers now called "Saturday Night Live.")

By the time of 1993's Breaking Silence, and with nearly two decades of middling sales and record label hostility, Ian was picking up recording time in fits and starts as money allowed, and with no record label behind her, she believed that this might be her last record. Ian bared her soul in full on Breaking Silence, covering topics including incest, spousal abuse and the Holocaust, while also making the difficult decision to come out publicly as a lesbian. Breaking Silence sold only 35,000 copies, and she and the Morgan Creek label split soon after, but the energy was out in the universe, and it came back to her with new opportunities; the album was nominated for a Grammy, and glowing reviews brought renewed interest in Ian's music.

After a short period on new age label Windham Hill, Ian took her business career in her own hands and started Rude Girl Music, named for a stinging remark made against her by an interviewer in the late '60s. Her 2002 essay "The Internet Debacle" won her new tech-savvy fans (your author included) with its passionate, nuanced defense of filesharing as a useful tool for artists whose work was left to languish by record label A&R eager only for the next multi-platinum hit. At a time when the recording industry pushed against the encroachment of new technology, "The Internet Debacle" and its follow-up essay again made her new allies and plenty of furious enemies. Of course, she accurately predicted the rise of iTunes and other legal MP3s-for-sale sites that allow musicians to target select audiences while giving listeners more customized buying options for music. (Greatest Hits packages with one new unreleased song, your time is up.)

Meanwhile, Ian's frank discussion of her sexuality has made her a lively guest on programs like The Howard Stern Show, while her regular column for The Advocate was ironically terminated for being too provocative (in part, she suspects, because of her passionate defense of Stern and his show). Collaborations with Ani DiFranco have introduced her songs to a new generation of guitar-rattling troubadours, and her 2006 album, Folk Is the New Black (again released on Rude Girl), is one of her most topical and risk-taking yet, comparable in its social and political viscera to Neil Young's Living With War.

Recently, Ian spoke before the Metro School Librarians in Nashville about the crucial role that reading played in her early life and on the life of the country. "It is difficult to subdue a fully literate people," she said. "They are exposed to too many different trains of thought. They are taught to question, to challenge, to argue. In our respect for literacy, as in so many other things, we artists have a great deal in common with you." Ian's passion for science fiction inspired a 2004 anthology entitled Stars: Original Stories Based On the Songs of Janis Ian, featuring stories by John Varley, Mercedes Lackey, Orson Scott Card, and Ian herself. (You can hear her ode to the sci-fi authors that changed her life, "Welcome Home," on her free MP3 page.)

In addition, Ian has also begun teaching what she calls "Master Classes," talking to local performers and writers about her experiences and her working methods. When I spoke to her on the phone, Ms. Ian said that she felt that even non-performers could benefit, and that through the classes, she hopes to "show the nobility of the artist in society." (A recent master class was pressed as a limited edition 2CD set and sold on the Janis Ian website.)

Whether you've been with her since the Gaslight folk club scene in the '60s or you just discovered her on the internet, Janis Ian welcomes you to the live experience. It can bring laughter (check out the sweetly tart "Married In London" on her free MP3 page) or tears (especially mine if she plays "Lover's Lullaby"!). It's the ache of being aware mixed with the joy of being alive. And rude.

Janis Ian performs at SPACE in Evanston (1245 Chicago Ave., Evanston) on Friday, Sept. 9, at 8pm. Tickets range from $25-$40. Her autobiography, Society's Child, is available at fine bookstores everywhere, as well as on the author's website.

GB store

David Gardiner / September 2, 2011 10:19 AM

Great article. Beautifully written. Why don't you come and join us on the Janis Ian Forum at ?

Chris S. / September 4, 2011 5:35 PM

Will do, David. Thanks!! Glad you liked the article.

GB store

Feature Thu Dec 31 2015

Our Final Transmission Days

By The Gapers Block Transmission Staff

Transmission staffers share their most cherished memories and moments while writing for Gapers Block.

Read this feature »


  Chicago Music Media

Alarm Magazine
Big Rock Candy Mountain
Boxx Magazine
Brooklyn Vegan Chicago
Can You See The Sunset From The Southside
Chicago Reader Music
Chicagoist Arts & Events
Chicago Music Guide
Chicago Singles Club
Country Music Chicago
Cream Team
Dark Jive
The Deli Chicago
Jim DeRogatis
Fake Shore Drive
Gowhere Hip Hop
The Hood Internet
Jaded in Chicago
Largehearted Boy
Little White Earbuds
Live Fix Blog
Live Music Blog
Loud Loop Press
Oh My Rockness
Pop 'stache
Pop Matters
Resident Advisor
Sound Opinions
Sun-Times Music Blog
Theft Liable to Prosecution
Tribune Music
UR Chicago
Victim Of Time
WFMU's Beware of the Blog
Windy City Rock


Abbey Pub
Andy's Jazz Club
Aragon Ballroom
Auditorium Theatre
Beat Kitchen
Bottom Lounge
Buddy Guy's Legends
The Burlington
California Clipper
Concord Music Hall
Congress Theater
Cubby Bear
Double Door
Elbo Room
Empty Bottle
Green Mill
The Hideout
Honky Tonk BBQ
House of Blues
Kingston Mines
Lincoln Hall
Logan Square Auditorium
Mayne Stage
The Mutiny
Old Town School of Folk Music
Park West
The Promontory
Red Line Tap
Reggie's Rock Club & Music Joint
The Riviera
Thalia Hall
The Shrine
Symphony Center
Tonic Room
Uncommon Ground
The Vic
The Whistler

  Labels, Promoters
  & Shops:

Alligator Records
Beverly Records
Bloodshot Records
Dave's Records
Delmark Records
Drag City
Dusty Groove
Flameshovel Records
Groove Distribution
He Who Corrupts
Jam Productions
Jazz Record Mart
Kranky Records
Laurie's Planet of Sound
Minty Fresh
Numero Group
mP Shows
Permanent Records
Reckless Records
Smog Veil Records
Southport & Northport Records
Thick Records
Thrill Jockey Records Touch & Go/Quarterstick Records
Victory Records

GB store


Featured Series


Transmission on Flickr

Join the Transmission Flickr Pool.

About Transmission

Transmission is the music section of Gapers Block. It aims to highlight Chicago music in its many varied forms, as well as cover touring acts performing in the city. More...
Please see our submission guidelines.

Editor: Sarah Brooks,
Transmission staff inbox:



Transmission Flickr Pool
 Subscribe in a reader.

GB store

GB Store

GB Buttons $1.50

GB T-Shirt $12

I ✶ Chi T-Shirts $15